Tuesday, May 14, 2024

RECENCY BIAS AND THE SUPREME COURT: THE PROBLEM IS THE INSTITUTION, NOT THE PEOPLE WHO SIT ON IT Eric J. Segall

 
By Eric J. Segall* [Georgia State]

You seem to consider the judges as ultimate arbiters of all constitutional questions; a very dangerous doctrine, indeed, and one which would place us under the despotism of an oligarchy. The constitution has erected no such single tribunal. –Thomas Jefferson

I. INTRODUCTION 

There is rampant and substantial despair on the political left (and maybe in the center as well) about the Supreme Court’s six-three conservative majority. In just a few years, the Court has decimated women’s reproductive freedoms, enlarged gun rights, essentially ended affirmative action, read the Free Exercise Clause broadly, deleted the  Establishment Clause from the Constitution, and is dramatically cutting back the ability of the administrative state to handle difficult national problems.  The dread is justified. 

This new ultra-conservative Court, after Senator Mitch McConnell’s norm-breaking manipulation of the confirmation process, led to President Biden’s Supreme Court reform commission, which has had no lasting effect and is now just a blip from the past. Additionally, the new “ethics code” the Justices signed on to has no enforcement mechanism and does not count as meaningful reform....

No comments:

Post a Comment