Showing posts with label Sixth Amendment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sixth Amendment. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 3, 2010

Trial by Jury: the Public's Right to Judge the 9/11 Defendants



 When Eric Holder says he wants to try, convict, and sentence to death the accused 9/11 planners  Sen. Charles Grassley acts like Holder wants to bake them a cake.  Grassley objects in a recent  letter to  President Obama that

"A trial would provide "unprivileged enemy belligerents a venue to spew their hateful rhetoric; creating new public terrorist targets out of our federal courthouses.... providing non-U.S. citizen terrorists constitutional protections associated with criminal prosecutions; and providing terrorists more rights than our military men and women when they are subject to a court-martial. "
The rhetorical device employed by Grassley - a member of the Judiciary Committee - is to put the words terrorist, rights, and Democrat, Holder, or Obama  close together.  The smear tactic is widely employed by the political right, as this post on Think Progress details.  Grassley continues
Additionally, Attorney General Holder also referred some detainees who are charged with attacking the U.S.S. Cole back to the Department of Defense for trial via military commission.
In splitting the prosecutions into two categories, it appears that the Attorney General has created a system which allows the terrorist to select the forum for justice by simply choosing to select a civilian or military target. 
But the Administration has drawn the line at a perfectly sensible place: those who attacked civilians deserve to be tried before a civilian court.  As Justice Anthony Kennedy emphasized in a civil context in Edmonson v. Leesville Concrete, 500 U.S. 614 (1991) trial by jury is not simply a right of the litigant.  The opportunity to be a member of a jury  is a public right of citizenship which  may not be arbitrarily denied.  Justice Antonin Scalia has described the jury as the "spinal column" of democracy. Neder v. United States, 527 U.S. 1, 30 (1999).

The Sixth Amendment provides for  "speedy and public trial by an impartial jury in the state and district where the crime shall have occurred."  The jury is an important democratic institution.  The jury is  not only a barrier to arbitrary government conduct, but also is the bulwark of  citizens' participation in the justice system, of the public's opportunity to judge the accused.  Trial by jury brings  the judgment of the community.   That a court martial cannot accomplish.  There, even when we adhere to the Uniform Code of Military Justice, every participant - judge, jury, prosecutor, and defender - is a member of the military chain of command.

Regrettably  little attention has been paid to this important aspect of Justice Department's intention to try the accused terrorists in the United States District Courts.


Saturday, January 30, 2010

At risk: my right to be a KSM juror



Images: U.S. Courthouse, Foley Square, below left; Governor's Island, right


I want to be a juror in the trial of Khalid Shaikh Mohammed.  Like all New Yorkers I think I am  tough on terror.  I watched the twin towers burn with fright that my son might have gone to work early that day.  


But now the professional toughs on terror want to take that opportunity away from me.  South Carolina Senator Lindsey Graham has announced he will introduce legislation to bar civilian trials for the accused 9/11 planners.  Disparagement of our civilian justice system - which people like Rudy Giuliani used to celebrate when the 1993 WTC bombers were convicted - has now become de rigeur among those like him who pose as toughs on terror for Rupert Murdoch's outlets.

The Constitution says that people like me should judge those who violated the peace of our City:

Amendment VI, Constitution of the United States of America

In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the state and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witnesses against him; to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the assistance of counsel for his defense.

"Obama blinked" the New York Daily News said today of the Administration's decision to abandon the plan to try Khalid Shaikh Mohammed and other accused 9/11 planners in downtown Manhattan.  After the police Commissioner Raymond Kelly described security plans that would have disrupted life in lower Manhattan for months, Mayor Michael Bloomberg reversed his stance and opposed the Foley Square venue.  
Don't do me any favors.  I don't mind giving up lunch at my favorite places in Chinatown.  I'll go to Governor's Island or even out of district to Fort Hamilton.  But I will very much mind if I, a citizen of the "state and district wherein the crime (was) committed",  am deprived (by statute or  failure of political nerve) of the chance to judge those who are accused of sending suicide commandos to destroy the towers and the thousands who were there that dreadful morning.  I want to make sure they have got the right guys.  And if the defendants are guilty I want the privilege of passing judgment on them.