Showing posts with label Hartnett. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hartnett. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 15, 2010

Seeking a path to restore order in the N.J. Supreme Court | NJ.com

Prof. Ed Hartnett
proposes rescue of Justice Rivera Soto
Justice Roberto Rivera Soto heavily relied on Seton Hall Prof. Edward Hartnett to justify his refusal to vote on cases being decided by the New Jersey Supreme Court.   In an Op-Ed piece in the Star Ledger  Hartnett offers Governor Christie a way to by-pass the State Senate, eliminating the vacancy which produced the temporary assignment to which Rivera Soto objects: a recess appointment by Gov. Chris Christie.
Seeking a path to restore order in the N.J. Supreme Court | NJ.com

My comments:


Associate Justice Rivera Soto believes that with a temporarily assigned judge voting  the New Jersey Supreme Court is illegitimate as constituted.  He refuses to participate in its judgments  so long as the court sits with such a temporary justice (except if needed for a quorum).   Prof. Hartnett seeks to excuse  Rivera Soto's boycott of court votes by saying that U.S. Supreme Court judges Brennan and Marshall consistently refused to join in their court's rulings on certain categories of issues on which they disagreed with the majority.   But they were dissenters not abstainers. And he suggests a Governor's recess appointment of stalled nominee Anne Patterson.  That would vindicate Rivera Soto - who would then return to voting on cases because the temporarily assigned judge would no longer be sitting.


It would set a terrible precedent if such a guerrilla tactic as Rivera Soto's were rewarded with success.


It is the duty of a judge to decide.  The parties and the people are owed the duty of adjudication.


Abstention by a judge is rarely appropriate but sometimes necessary.  It is employed principally when a personal conflict may prevent the judge from upholding her duty of competent and impartial judgment: as when she has an interest in the outcome, or her physical limitations threaten her ability to render fair and competent judgment.


Justice Rivera Soto cited the example of Justice Harry Blackmun to justify his refusal to judge the cases  before him.  But in his passion Justice Rivera Soto failed to determine the facts.  In 1976 Justice Harry Blackmun voted to allow executions to resume - in the belief that it could be fairly and consistently employed.  18 years later he had despaired of that.  In Callins v. Callins he declared "From this day forward I shall no longer tinker with the machinery of death."


But from that day forward Justice Blackmun did not abstain.  He participated in every case - of every kind - before the court.  And in death cases he dissented.  He dissented even from denials of certification, in what came to be known as `Callins dissents', which recited the conclusion  he had reached after twenty years of trying to fairly enforce the death penalty: that it is an impossible task and that the punishment is administered so arbitrarily that it is unconstitutional.


It would behoove Justice Rivera Soto to embrace Justice Blackmun's example.  He owes a duty to conscience to dissent on issues of principle relevant to the cases before him; and to abide by the judgment of the court thereafter.  The Court on which he sits or the judgment of the people may someday vindicate his view that the Chief Justice's interpretation of the New Jersey Constitution is wrong.   But the remedy announced by Justice Soto "abstention" is, to use his phrase, ultra vires - outside of law and precedent.  Justice Rivera Soto should without delay resume exercise of the full duties of a judge of the Supreme Court.
- GWC   12/15/10