Monday, October 1, 2012

Argument recap: In search of an ATS compromise : SCOTUSblog


Update:  Alberto Bernabe has collected commentary on the ATS argument at his Torts Blog

Kiobel v. Royal Dutch Shell was re-argued today. The result could immunize corporations which aid tyrannies from liability under the Alien Tort Statute (ATS). In fact it could render the ATS a nullity for non-citizens harmed in other countries despite the law's broad protecive language. The plaintiff's Alien Tort Statute case in Kiobel v. Royal Dutch Shell appears to be in grave jeopardy. There was not much support today at re-argument in the Supreme Court for this claim by a foreign national against a foreign corporation for conduct that occurred entirely outside the United States. Sonia Sotomayor appeared to embrace the approach urged by the European Commission: that the U.S. courts should provide a "forum by necessity" where there was no remedy where the rights violation occurred. - gwc

Argument recap: In search of an ATS compromise : SCOTUSblog:
by Lyle Denniston
Paul L. Hoffman, a California lawyer representing Nigerian nationals claiming killing and torture in their homeland, faced claims that his approach would mean no limits on a worldwide pursuit of human rights justice, potentially disrupting diplomatic relations generally. Kathleen M. Sullivan, a New York lawyer for the big foreign oil companies sued in the case and seeking to head off almost all ATS claims, encountered suggestions that her view would cut back even on ATS claims that the Court has already allowed. And U.S. Solicitor General Donald B. Verrilli, Jr., arguing against the Kiobel claim but pleading to keep the courts open to at least some ATS cases, ran up against arguments that he was switching away unpersuasively from the more clear-cut position taken by the government in the past...

Sunday, September 30, 2012

Three lawyers ask Supreme Court to Spurn Alien Tort claims act cases | Reuters


Conservative superstar lawyer Paul Clement - who lost the Obamacare case - has teamed up with John Bellinger - a former Bush administration State Department lawyer - to destroy the 1789 Alien Tort Statute (28 USC 1350) which has been used to bring suit for human rights violations against foreign states and corporations.  The U.S. lacks jurisdiction over such claims, they argued in a friend of the court brief in Kiobel v. Royal Dutch Shell.  The conservative Supreme Court justices saw an opportunity and schedled reargument.  The Court appears poised to gut the ATS. - GWC

Insight: Three lawyers ask U.S. Supreme Court: Why here? | Reuters:
 By Rebecca Hamilton 
"For more than three decades survivors of human rights abuses in foreign countries have turned to U.S. federal courts to seek justice. On Monday the U.S. Supreme Court hears a case that could make that impossible."
h/t John Steel - Legal Ethics Forum

'via Blog this'

Robert Francis, the Texan judge closing America's jails | World news | The Observer

texan judge robert francis
Texas Judge Robert Francis
Drug courts - a big trend in criminal justice - championed most prominently not by sympathetic social workers but by Republican who have overcome their tough on crime bent by recognizing that jails are costly and unsuccessful. Rehab reduces recidivism is the message.  - gwc 
Robert Francis, the Texan judge closing America's jails | World news | The Observer:
They are beneficiaries of a revolution in justice sweeping the United States, one with illuminating lessons for Britain. It is a revolt led by hardline conservatives who have declared prison a sign of state failure. They say it is an inefficient use of taxpayers' money when the same people, often damaged by drink, drugs, mental health problems or chaotic backgrounds, return there again and again.
Remarkably, this revolution was unleashed in "hang 'em high" Texas, which prides itself on its toughness and still holds more executions than other states. But instead of building more prisons and jailing ever more people, Texas is now diverting funds to sophisticated rehabilitation programmes to reduce recidivism. Money has been poured into probation, parole and specialist services for addicts, the mentally ill, women and veterans. And it has worked: figures show even violent crime dropping at more than twice the national average, while cutting costs and reducing prison populations.
'via Blog this'

Saturday, September 29, 2012

The N.F.L. Lockout and the Modern Economy - NYTimes.com

The NFL locked out the football referees to kill their pension plan, convert it to a 401k, which transfers the risk of loss to labor.  That's the modern way - now that socialism is dead.  The Dean of the school of management at the University of Toronto calls a spade a spade.  - gwc
The N.F.L. Lockout and the Modern Economy - NYTimes.com
by Roger L.Martin
"But why the lockout, and why did the N.F.L. fight so hard? Because the league was fighting a bigger fight, one that is representative of a war beneath the surface of the modern economy — the war between capital and talent. Since the Industrial Revolution, two groups have fought for the spoils of their joint production. On one side is capital — the owners and investors who provide the means of production. On the other side is labor — the workers who turn invested capital into profits. "...

'via Blog this'

Friday, September 28, 2012

Sen. Jim Webb on `givers and takers'

Jim Webb (D-VA), who is not running for re-election, choosing to spend only a single term in the Senate speaks powerfully about veterans benefits at an Obama rally.   An ex-Marine - like his father and son - he served in the Reagan administration then ran for Senate as a Democrat.

Gallup: race is Obama's to lose

Barack Obama has a strong lead over Mitt Romney.  It's the President's race to lose.  Not long ago triumphant Tea Partiers were wearing buttons that said "Is it 2012 yet?".  Talk of the unconstitutionality of `Obamacare' was rife.  What happened?  The Republican primaries, I would say.  That long running TV show drove Romney - a non-ideological center-right politician sharply to the right.  It turned the campaign into what Senator Lindsey Graham (R-SC) called a "demographic election".  The Republican Party's attachment to bible belt white conservatism appears to be its undoing. - GWC

Thursday, September 27, 2012

The 47% - Romney in his own words

I have a high regard for Jonathan Bernstein, John Sides, et al - political scientists and commentators whose work I follow on their blogs - A Plain Blog About Politics ((JB) and The Monkey Cage (Sides, et al.).  They have a respect for data which I appreciate for keeping narrative history types like me from getting too far off track.  But the general take they have is gaffes don't matter, they're just indistinguishable blips that don't move the partisans and are too small to identifiably move the undecided - who are, after all what swings elections.  But my quarrel is with identifiable.  You can overdo generalizing from past gaffes.  At some point you have to say that the beat of the heart matters.  It did for John Kerry and I think it will for Mitt Romney.  But Gov. Romney's damage will be worse for being self-inflicted.

I think that John Kerry had an uphill fight (don't switch horses in the middle of the stream - even when the stream was the horrors of the post-invasion Iraq civil war).  But I think that Swift Boating hurt.  So easy to say "oh, another self promoter" who got a Silver Star cause he is a rich guy, a politician.  Here are guys who were there (well, nearby).  And they say he was just a successful opportunist."  I think it had an effect - because the charges were irrebutable (you weren't there).  The Swift Boaters' accusations neutralized the theme Kerry put at the center of his personal message "I am John Kerry and I am reporting for duty".

The Obama campaign obviously thinks the heart matters too.  I agree - the power of the 47% meme is much greater than the Swift Boat meme - because it seems to be Mitt Romney himself speaking from the heart.  Below is the new Obama ad.  Mitt Romney audio, 47%'ers on the screen. - gwc

Wednesday, September 26, 2012

In the Bronx, Resistance to Prosecuting Stop-and-Frisk Arrests - NYTimes.com

Robert Johnson - the Bronx D.A. - has taken the bold step of putting a spanner in the street patrols that subject residents of public housing projects to a reign of random searches and, often arrest.  Prosecutors often have trouble remembering that the public, not the police, are their clients.  Cops and prosecutors are, naturally, a team.  But the culture of aggressive patrols which characterize life on the street for Black and Hispanic New Yorkers has eroded police and prosecutors respect for basic principles like the need for reasonable suspicion to stop a person and probable cause for arrest.  One of the nastiest tricks is to stop people,  compel them to empty their pockets, then arresting them for open public possession of the marijuana cigaret the unwarranted search forced into the open.  - GWC 
The Times reports:
In the Bronx, Resistance to Prosecuting Stop-and-Frisk Arrests - NYTimes.com:
by Joseph Goldstein

In a significant blow to New York City’s use of stop-and-frisktactics, the Bronx district attorney’s office is no longer prosecuting people who were stopped at public housing projects and arrested for trespassing, unless the arresting officer is interviewed to ensure that the arrest was warranted.

Readers’ Comments

Prosecutors quietly adopted the policy in July after discovering that many people arrested on charges of criminal trespass at housing projects were innocent, even though police officers had provided written statements to the contrary.
By essentially accusing the police of wrongfully arresting people, the stance taken by Bronx prosecutors is the first known instance in which a district attorney has questioned any segment of arrests resulting from stop-and-frisk tactics.....


'via Blog this'

Working Conditions: The Persistence of Problems in China's Factories - China Real Time Report - WSJ

Police riot squad outside an iPhone factory
China's proletariat - whose dictatorship is the declared form of rule - labors under lamentable conditions.  Despite formal legal protections many work under sweatshop conditions, shortchanged on wages, health, and social insurance by law-breaking companies.  Prominent are those that make our favorite gadgets like iPhones.  I often look at China and see what Gunnar Myrdal called a "soft state" in his classic Asian Drama.  Workers rights are declared in China but are unreliably enforced. - GWC Working Conditions: The Persistence of Problems in China's Factories - China Real Time Report - WSJ: "By Stanley Lubman
A riot involving 2,000 workers at a factory in the northern Chinese city of Taiyuan on Sunday night has once again shined a light on conditions at factories owned by Apple Inc. supplier Foxconn. The cause of the riot appears to have been a fight between workers that somehow escalated into larger-scale unrest. While the precise dynamics that led workers in the factory to run rampant remain unclear, it’s noteworthy that news of the incident comes with Apple recently announcing that advance sales of its iPhone5 have broken all previous records. The success of the iPhone and similar products means competition among companies like Apple and Samsung, both of which rely heavily on Chinese factory supply chains, is likely to increase. This increase in competition, in turn, will crank up pressures in factories whose workers are already struggling under harsh conditions"
'via Blog this'

Tuesday, September 25, 2012

President Obama at the UN - waving the flag of reason and freedom

Among the editorial board members at the New Jersey Law Journal we debated how to frame the right response to the tragedies following the recent anti-Muslim video by a Los Angeles-based provocateur.  In an editorial called "Blasphemy" we explained: 
Whoever Bakoula and his backers are, our government has done its duty by making it clear that under our law the United States cannot prevent this kind of stupid and malicious provocation and is not responsible for anything, however vile, that private individuals choose to say about someone else's religion. It is true that other free countries do these things differently. Based on the experience of fascism, many European countries prescribe racist or anti-religious speech. So do countries like India, which have a long history of intercommunal violence. Great offense has been given, and diplomacy requires the government to regret what Nakoula has said. But both candor to the world and our national values require us remind the world why it can freely be said here.  But both candor to the world and our national values require us remind the world why it can freely be said here.
President Obama eloquently delivered the message we hoped he would at the UN General Assembly today.  

Monday, September 24, 2012

Beyond Guns & God - the complex politics of the white working class

President Obama once regrettably remarked that some people are bitter and "cling to guns and religion".  Brian, erstwhile owner of Brian's wharf, Hatchet Cove, Friendship, Maine has a decal on his pickup truck that says "Guts, Guns & God - we need all three".  This despite the fact that nobody around town has ever used a gun to ward off an intruder, or protect himself against a police garrison state.  God has helped him find his way free of the sauce, and guts has served him well in a life of fishing - hauling traps and boxes of bait.  But his guns have never bagged more than deer.  Now comes the Public Religion Research Institue (PRRI) to instruct us in a nuanced way on how working class and the college-educated people see god, guns, and guts.   Turns out where you are may be more important than who you are.  = GWC

Romney: Uninsured Can Go To The Emergency Room (VIDEO) | TPMDC

Romney: Uninsured Can Go To The Emergency Room (VIDEO) | TPMDC: 'via Blog this'

Saturday, September 22, 2012

Rory Stewart's sorrowful assessment of the Afghanistan project | xpostfactoid

Rory Stewart's sorrowful assessment of the Afghanistan project | xpostfactoid:
by Rory StewartRory Stewart, the man who walked across central Afghanistan in winter, and later urged light-touch, sustainable engagement underpinned by modest expectations, is back with a sorrowful assessment of the West's options as the training mission collapses:
"In the absence of “victory”, three alternative strategies have been proposed: training the Afghan security forces, political settlement with the Taliban and a regional solution. But training Afghan forces, which cost $12bn in 2010 alone, will not guarantee their future loyalty to a Kabul government. Two years and many regional conferences have passed since the formation of the Afghan Higher Peace council, and the clear Nato endorsement of reconciliation: but there is no sign that insurgents, the Kabul government or its neighbours will reach a deal, or feel much desire so to do. So there is no military solution, and no political solution either. Nor will there be before the troops leave. We will have to deal for decades with a troubled Afghanistan, which is not likely in my lifetime to be as wealthy as Libya, as effectively governed as Iraq, as educated as Syria, or as institutionally mature as Pakistan. "

'via Blog this'

A record to run on | xpostfactoid

Obama's message is jelling | xpostfactoid:
by Andrew Sprung
We often hear that Romney has a challenger's advantage in a down economy. He can stick to a simple message: the economy is broken and Obama can't fix it -- I can.  And the Romney campaign has indicated that he regards offering detail as a disadvantage and distraction. Don't say what you'd cut; don't say what tax loopholes you'd close or what "simple, effective" regulation would look like; just offer yourself as a problem solver who "knows how jobs come and how they go."
Such a strategy could work if the economic news is bad enough. But there's a flip side. Obama, unlike Romney, has a record to run on -- a record of engagement with national problems that he doesn't have to run away from, as Romney does from his signature achievement as governor of Massachusetts. And now, Obama is running on that record. Here he is at UVA on Aug. 29, combating the notion that he failed to bring hope and change: 
'via Blog this'

Ezra Klein's unconvincing theory that Obama misunderstands (or misrepresents) "change" | xpostfactoid

Ezra Klein's unconvincing theory that Obama misunderstands (or misrepresents) "change" | xpostfactoid:
"Maybe not as far forward as in 2009-10. But as James Fallows argued at length, reaping the harvest of the potentially transformative legislation of those two years depends on Obama's reelection. The ultimate success of the ACA and Dodd-Frank depend on a long hard slog of implementation. Meaningful electoral reform depends on the next Supreme Court appointments. Continued effective environmental regulation depends on not letting in the dereg wrecking crew -- and that goes for virtually all regulatory channels. And as Obama says, he is holding the line against further rollback of women's rights. " 'via Blog this'

Friday, September 21, 2012

When Hitler learned about the secret Romney video

All hell broke loose.  For any reader who is not a political junkie the target is not Romey but Jennifer Rubin - the conservative attack schnauzer who writes the Right Turn column for the Washington Post. - GWC

Thursday, September 20, 2012

Democrats for Nixon

That 47% number has a long pedigree in the politics of resentment. - GWC

Wednesday, September 19, 2012

If We’re Lucky, Romney’s Misguided Comments Will Remind The Public It Likes Government More Than It Realizes | The New Republic

Jonathan Cohn exlains that there are two key issues: first - who pays taxes and who receives government benefits.
Taxes: payroll taxes, and state sales  taxes are generally regressive: everyone pays the same sales tax, and Social Security (FICA) stops at about $105,000.  It is only income tax that is somewhat progressive.  And when it comes to that people who live on investment income pay low federal income taxes.  High salary earners (yes lawyers and mid-level executives) pay a lot more (around 25% like Obama and Biden) .
Second who receives government benefits and how costly are they?  Almost everyone (good), and how costly?  Well the poor are getting less and less (surprise).  But health care costs are going up.  That's a legitimate debate. Some (like me) think Medicare (single-payer) is the most efficient and desirable.  But that will leaves the questions of how to control costs - limit benefits, reduce compensation, or force systemic cost reductions (e.g. - decide based on evidence that some tests/treatments/medicines will not be covered.

- GWC
If We’re Lucky, Romney’s Misguided Comments Will Remind The Public It Likes Government More Than It Realizes | The New Republic:
by Jonathan Cohn
"Will Moocherpalooza have an impact on the presidential campaign? It might. Mitt Romney, Paul Ryan and their allies have been decrying the “entitlement society” and supposedly low number of Americans paying federal taxes for some time now. But the specific language and circumstances of Romney’s comments at a May fundraiser, first reported in Mother Jones on Monday, may capture the attention of average Americans in a way those previous speeches and writings did not. "

'via Blog this'

Trial and Error - ACLU Report on Prosecutorial Trial Error in New Jersey

A careful study of prosecutorial conduct by the New Jersey ACLU reaches some unsurprising conclusions: that [a]s general rule, prosecutors in New Jersey deserve praise for avoiding repeated error in the overwhelming majority of cases. But there is nonetheless significant repeated prosecutorial error which requires "policies that provide for training, supervision and discipline."  That "summation errors...continue to occur with “numbing frequency.” And that  courts must develop policies — including publicly naming offending prosecutors and reporting them to appropriate  bodies — that will ensure that prosecutorial error happens less often. 
The ACLU authors (including Rutgers law professor George C. Thomas, III) notably conclude, in their most dramatic recommendation that:
A system of mandatory reporting of all findings of prosecutorial error to the Office of the Attorney General would create a database to track prosecutors with repeated violations. 
Under this model, the Office of the Attorney General would be required to forward a complaint to the appropriate district ethics board whenever error contributed to a reversal of a conviction and whenever a prosecutor had been cited for a subsequent finding of error.
Trial and Error - A Comprehensive Study of Prosecutorial Conduct in New Jersey - ACLU of NJ
by Alexander Shalom and Prof. George Thomas
from the Executive Summary
As a whole, prosecutors understand the unique role they play in the administration of justice and take their responsibilities seriously. They seek diligently to avoid errors that could undermine both the integrity of the criminal justice system and the validity of their hard-fought convictions. They proceed confident in the knowledge that they seek not only convictions, but justice, and often without competitive remuneration.
When prosecutors err, and transgress rules established for their conduct, they generally learn from their mistakes and avoid repeated missteps. However, a small group of prosecutors commits multiple errors without seeming to learn from those missteps. This American Civil Liberties Union of New Jersey study aims to survey comprehensively prosecutorial error in New Jersey by examining the prevalence of error and determining which errors occur most frequently.
After compiling the foundational data, the study’s authors quantitatively analyzed the data’s meaning. Specifically, researchers examined the extent of inter-county disparities among rates of error, correlations between error and experience and prevalence of individual prosecutors with repeated instances of error.  The report examines the contexts in which prosecutors were cited for error on multiple occasions and explores the costs of prosecutorial error for criminal defendants,  for society and for individual prosecutors.


'via Blog this'

Monday, September 17, 2012

Romney: Obama Voters Pay No Taxes - Video - Mother Jones/TPM

Mitt Romney, born on third base, thinks he hit a triple - in Ann Richards memorable phrase.  Think he doesn't pay enough taxes?  Romney thinks Obama's voters are people who pay no income taxes and refuse to take responsibility, depend on government.  He'll spend a good deal of time explaining just what he meant in this fundraiser talk which will surely be heard in Democratic attack ads.  David Corn broke the story in Mother Jones, where there are lots more video clips = and more to come.  Josh Marshall reports. - GWC
Devastating | TPM Editors Blog: 'via Blog this'