by Sarah Posner
Monday, October 12, 2020
Trump's Christian Judges March On - Rolling Stone
by Sarah Posner
Sunday, October 11, 2020
Trump’s Swamp: Taxes Trace Payments to Properties by Those Who Got Ahead - The New York Times
Trump’s Swamp: Taxes Trace Payments to Properties by Those Who Got Ahead - The New York Times
Saturday, October 10, 2020
Court Packing as an Antidote by Rivka Weill :: SSRN
by Rivka Weill [Herzliyah - Radzyner School of Law]
H-Block and Armagh Prisons Independent Panel Report Details the Systemic Inhumane Treatment of Prisoners | News | Garden Court Chambers | Leading Barristers located in London, UK
H-Block and Armagh Prisons Independent Panel Report Details the Systemic Inhumane Treatment of Prisoners | News | Garden Court Chambers | Leading Barristers located in London, UK
Friday, October 9, 2020
Amy Barrett: A Different Kind of Originalist | Commonweal Magazine
A Different Kind of Originalist | Commonweal Magazine
By Gregory Bassham
Thursday, October 8, 2020
Union County Lawyer Suspended for 2 Years Over Taxes, Mortgage Loans to Client | New Jersey Law Journal
By Charles Toutant
‘Exclusively in Cash’
Jim Dwyer, Pulitzer Prize-Winning Journalist, Dies at 63 - The New York Times

Jim Dwyer died this morning. At 63. Lung cancer. Like Jimmy Breslin, he had the common touch. A journalist in the tradition of the Front Page. Like Pete Hamill and Mike McAlary he was a tribune of the people, a reason to buy the New York Daily News or New York Newsday or any paper for which he wrote. He was a veteran of the New Jersey dailies in Jersey City, Elizabeth, and Hackensack. Jesuit educated (Loyola Prep and Fordham) we had that tribal link. I had the good fortune to, like him, be a regular for breakfast at Vicky's the local Greek diner on West 187 Street in Washington Heights, now a casualty of covid19. He loved my yellow Labs, tied up in front of the diner where I sat in the table by the window to keep them calm. He appreciated their names and personalities: Seamus Heaney, and James J. Muldoon, named for great Irish poets. His father, who never lost his Irish accent, often joined him for breakfast. Jim was a character in Nora Ephron's Lucky Guy about McAlary and the other New York tabloid heroes. Separated at breakfast by the corona virus, I didn't know he was ill. I'm sorry I did not get to say goodbye to a man who deserved a long life. - GWC
Jim Dwyer, Pulitzer Prize-Winning Journalist, Dies at 63 - The New York Times
By Robert D. McFadden
Second Circuit again rebuffs Trump attempt to block Manhattan Grand Jury Subpoena
The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit has again rebuffed Donald Trump’s efforts to block any investigator from getting access to his tax and other financial records via the subpoena issued by a New York Grand Jury to Trump's accountants Mazars, LLC.
Two hundred years ago, a great jurist of our Court established that no citizen, not even the President, is categorically above the common duty to produce evidence when called upon in a criminal proceeding. We reaffirm that principle today and hold that the President is neither absolutely immune from state criminal subpoenas seeking his private papers nor entitled to a heightened standard of need. - C.J. John Roberts in Trump v. Vance (2020)
But, said Roberts:
"a President may avail himself of the same protections available to every other citizen. These include the right to challenge the subpoena on any grounds permitted by state law, which usually include bad faith and undue burden or breadth.
On remand from the Supreme Court, the President filed a Second Amended Complaint (SAC) in federal district court in Manhattan, under 42 USC 1983, for broad relief:
a. A declaratory judgment that the subpoena is invalid and unenforceable.
b. A permanent injunction quashing or modifying the subpoena as necessary to protect the President’s legal rights.
c. A permanent injunction prohibiting the District Attorney from taking any action to enforce the subpoena, from imposing sanctions for noncompliance with the subpoena, and from
inspecting, using, maintaining, or disclosing any information obtained as a result of the subpoena.
The Circuit court recounts that Trump and the companies he owns and controls allege that the subpoena to Mazars is overbroad and was issued in bad faith. On overbreadth, the SAC alleges that many of the requested documents bear no relation to the payments made by Michael Cohen in 2016—which the SAC, relying on a contemporaneous New York Times article and the earlier subpoena to the Trump Organization, characterizes as the “focus” of the grand jury investigation. The SAC also notes the broad scope and timeframe of the Mazars subpoena to argue that the subpoena exceeds the District Attorney’s jurisdiction. Finally, the SAC alleges that the Mazars subpoena is overbroad and must have been issued in bad faith because it largely mirrors a legislative subpoena issued to Mazars by the House Committee on Oversight and Reform.
In a per curiam opinion issued October 7 the panel unanimously affirmed Judge Victor Marrero’s dismissal of the complaint filed by Trump. Judges Robert Katzmann, Pierre Leval and Raymond Lohier found that the overbreadth allegations did not meet the test of plausibility which a complaint must satisfy in a federal court in order to defeat a motion to dismiss under FRCP 12 (b)(5). “Similarly, the President’s allegations of bad faith fail to raise a plausible inference that the subpoena was issued out of malice or an intent to harass.”
The President’s lawyers sought to accomplish what they had failed to do in the first place, and the second, and the third - at the United States Supreme Court. On remand the Trump lawyers filed a complaint alleging that the state prosecutor - here New York County District Attorney Cyrus Vance, Jr. - was acting in bad faith. Proceeding under the post civil war era civil rights act 42 USC 1983 - the Trump complaint echoed the allegations in the landmark case of Dombrowski v. Pfister (1965). But there the Louisiana prosecutors were proceeding under the state’s Communist Control Act. The Louisiana statute was identical to a Washington State law that the Supreme Court had declared unconstitutional. So there the allegation of bad faith was more than plausible. Further dooming the Trump effort to block the subpoena is the doctrine of deference to state law and prosecutors which is deeply embedded in the law. See, for example, Younger v. Harris (1972) which further constrained federal courts ability to interfere in state prosecutions.
The parties on October 2 agreed on an expedited briefing schedule including that if the District Attorney prevailed the DA will "forbear" enforcement and the Trump parties will within five days seek relief from the United States Supreme Court.
Monday, October 5, 2020
Thomas and Alito: "ruinous consequences" for religious liberty
The Obergefell case, recognizing the right to marriage of same sex couples, has had "ruinous consequences" for religious liberty, Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Samuel Alito, has warned in a statement on the denial of certiorari in the case of Kentucky Clerk Jean Davis.
The two deplore the decision because the matter should have been left to the elected branches of government on a state by state basis. Instead those who, like orthodox Catholics, embrace the Catechism which, despite Pope Francis softer stand, still labels homosexuality as "intrinsically disordered", may be treated as bigots by unelected judges.
Thomas and Alito may feel emboldened by the expected arrival of Amy Coney Barrett. She has taken a similar tack in dissent approving Trump administration policies like the "public charge" rule barring indigent immigrants. Chief Justice Roberts too dissented from the Obergefell decision so Barrett, a Catholic pentecostal, will make four votes. That leave Brett Kavanaugh to provide the fifth vote to overturn the uncertainly founded Obergefell opinion of his protector and sponsor Anthony Kennedy.
The Thomas Alito statement portends much posturing about precedent, reliance, state sovereignty and deference to the popular will. It also poses a strong challenge to the one nation idea that equal protection means the same thing in Alabama as it does in Massachusetts.
Sunday, October 4, 2020
We have a political problem no one wants to talk about: very old politicians - Vox
I am a strong supporter of the elder of the candidates. But should he really contemplate a second term? Finish up at 87, like Chuck Grassley who is still clinging to the Judiciary Committee gavel?
When I was younger (not young) I readily began long term projects. I started studying Chinese at 60. Still plugging away. But should I - at soon to be 75 - embark on new long term projects? That's not a rhetorical question. It's a question. I oppose term limits, but would we choose life tenure for judges again? Shouldn't we term limit them? At full pay, fine. Subject to recall...fine. But do you think that our octogenarian judges know what is happening in the culture? Or do you think it doesn't matter? - gwc
We have a political problem no one wants to talk about: very old politicians - Vox
by Harold Pollack (University of Chicago)
Friday, October 2, 2020
The Case for Ending the Supreme Court as We Know It | The New Yorker

African-Americans lined up to attend oral argument in
Brown v. Board of Education 1954
The Case for Ending the Supreme Court as We Know It | The New Yorker
By Keeanga-Yamahtta Taylor
Super-spreader 101 - Everywhere that Donald went the virus was sure to go - Politicoagnosis
Where Trump went (and who he was with) leading up to his coronavirus diagnosis - POLITICO
Who done it?



