Sunday, November 1, 2009

PRC 60th anniversary - Stanley Lubman on rule of law in China

China's Legal Reforms ( S.c. C. ), Stanley B. Lubman, 0198233442

Stanley Lubman preaches "cautious pessimism" toward progress on the rule of law in China at the 60th anniversary of the People's Republic of China. Modest optimism might be a more accurate formulation - but it is de rigeur for western commentators to see the glass as half-empty. The Berkeley law prof's essay is posted on the Wall Street Journal's
China Real time Report blog.

Lubman's Bird in a Cage was one of the first serious treatments of the developments in the PRC legal system. He notes the great increase in professionalism in the Chinese judiciary and in its burgeoning law schools. My own experience - principally via the strong friendships I have formed with half a dozen Chinese law professors over the past 9 years - is that Chinese lawyers are serious and meticulous about the law. They are conveying this attitude, methods, and values to their students. It is noteworthy that law is an undergraduate degrees and that Chinese universities are producing thousands of graduates who have majored in law.

1 comment:

  1. Geroge: Thanks for this. My own friendships with Chinese law professors have yielded the same opinions as yours-- but of law professors, not necessarily of Chinese lawyers, who sometimes have very different values. I would be interested to know more about your own experiences, and look forward to hearing from you. Kind regards, Stanley

    ReplyDelete